Fiction Writing Tips, Tested Against 14 Classic Novels

Fiction writing tips checked against the books: we counted adverbs after said, exclamation marks and suddenly in 14 classic novels. Which famous rules hold up.

By Published November 19, 20267 min read

Try KudoNovel for free
  • No subscription needed
  • Unfiltered & uncensored
  • Story Bible that updates itself

The fiction writing tips that hold up are the ones about what a reader feels: give every character something they want, start as late in the story as you can, and cut what readers skip. The ones about punctuation and single words are tastes. We tested three of Elmore Leonard's famous rules (no adverb after "said", two or three exclamation marks per 100,000 words, never "suddenly") on 14 classic novels: only Hemingway's The Sun Also Rises comes close to the first, and none of the 14 comes within sixty times of the second. Below are the counts, then the tips for writing a fiction novel that the evidence backs, each linked to the guide that goes deeper.

Famous fiction writing tips, tested on 14 classic novels

Method (19 Nov 2026): the full text of 14 public-domain novels from Project Gutenberg, and a script that finds each speech tag right after a closing quotation mark ("…," said Poirot), checks whether an -ly word follows it ("said Poirot gravely"), and counts every "!" and every "suddenly" in the novel. It misses tags written other ways, so the tag counts are a floor; the comparison between books is what matters. The rules are Leonard's 10 rules of writing, first published in The New York Times on 16 July 2001.

Novel (year)Tags countedTags with an adverb"!" per 100,000 words"suddenly" per 100,000 words
Pride and Prejudice (1813)4683.8%33413
Frankenstein (1818)831.2%31735
Wuthering Heights (1847)9634.4%1,14613
Jane Eyre (1847)7364.2%50318
Alice's Adventures in Wonderland (1865)2556.3%1,70049
Little Women (1868)1,15513.1%40126
Treasure Island (1883)4202.9%43941
The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (1892)6586.1%33145
Dracula (1897)27611.2%46632
Peter Pan (1911)52920.2%49749
The Mysterious Affair at Styles (1920)42729.7%73073
The Great Gatsby (1925)38827.6%25783
The Sun Also Rises (1926)9770.2%19913
The Murder of Roger Ackroyd (1926)95627.8%29735
All 148,29111.5%49531

Source: KudoNovel's count of 14 Project Gutenberg texts, 19 Nov 2026.

What the counts say:

  • "Never use an adverb to modify 'said'" (Leonard's rule 4, "a mortal sin"). Hemingway kept it: 2 adverbs in 977 tags. Christie did the opposite and is still read: 266 of the 956 tags in Roger Ackroyd carry one ("said Poirot dryly"). The rule is a style, Hemingway's style, and it's a good default for a modern thriller.
  • "No more than two or three [exclamation points] per 100,000 words." Even The Sun Also Rises has 199 per 100,000. Nobody here comes within sixty times of Leonard's ceiling. The useful version: an exclamation mark in narration almost always reads as the author shouting; inside dialogue it's the character, and the classics use it there.
  • Never "suddenly". Gatsby says it 40 times in 48,000 words. Fitzgerald got away with it; most of us would be better off showing the jolt instead of naming it.

For the speech verbs themselves (said against cried, asked, replied), our guide to writing dialogue that sounds human counted ten of the same classics.

Tips for writing a fiction novel that hold up

These are the ones with the strongest backing: rules that working novelists put in writing, and that show up in the books readers keep.

Every character should want something. Kurt Vonnegut's third rule: "Every character should want something, even if it is only a glass of water" (from the introduction to Bagombo Snuff Box, 1999, as quoted by Open Culture). A scene goes flat when nobody in it wants anything. Our character arc guide turns the want into a shape across the book.

Start as close to the end as possible. Vonnegut's fifth rule, and Leonard's "avoid prologues" points the same way. Open on the moment things change, not the week before it. Our first line guide and prologue guide show when an opening earns its place.

Leave out the part readers skip. Leonard's tenth rule. In practice it means cutting the travel between scenes, the weather that changes nothing, and the second explanation of what the reader already understood. Our guide to fixing pacing in a novel shows where that skipped part usually hides.

Show the feeling, don't name it. "She was furious" tells; a slammed cup shows. Our show, don't tell examples are before/after pairs you can copy.

Make awful things happen to people you like. Vonnegut's sixth rule: "Be a sadist… make awful things happen to them", so the reader can see what they're made of. A romance heroine who gets everything she wants by chapter three has no book left.

Give the reader information early. Vonnegut's eighth and most argued-with rule: "Give your readers as much information as possible as soon as possible." It doesn't kill suspense; it moves it from "what's going on?" to "what will she do about it?", which is the better question.

Finish the draft, then fix it. The rules above are revision tools. Use them on a finished chapter, not while the first draft is still coming; our self-editing guide puts them in order.

How many people search for fiction writing tips

Keyword Planner, US, average monthly searches, read 19 November 2026:

QuerySearches a month
writing tips2,900
writing a novel tips880
fiction writing tips590
tips for writing a fiction novel590
fiction writing advice590
tips for writing a book590
short story writing tips480
tips for writing dialogue260

Source: KudoNovel's Keyword Planner pull, 19 Nov 2026.

What's the most important tip for writing a novel?

Finish it. Every rule on this page is about revising prose that exists. A first draft with adverbs and exclamation marks can be fixed; a blank page can't. If you're stuck, our guide to getting past writer's block starts there.

Are writing rules meant to be broken?

The counts above say most of the classics broke Leonard's rules all the time. Treat a rule as a question to ask of a sentence ("does this adverb add anything the line doesn't?"), not a law. Vonnegut himself wrote that Flannery O'Connor broke nearly all of his rules but the first.

Should you use AI to write fiction?

As a drafting partner on your own words, yes; as a replacement for having something to say, no. The test is simple: does the result still sound like you, and does it keep your book's facts straight? That's the job KudoNovel is built for.

Try the tips on your own chapter in KudoNovel

Reading about a rule is slow; seeing it applied to your own paragraph is fast. In KudoNovel you type a paragraph rough, the way first drafts come out, press Expand, and KudoAI writes it out as prose from your words. Then try a tip on it with Steer: highlight a line and type "cut the adverbs", "show her anger, don't name it" or "start later, at the slap". Each result is a version, so you can compare the before and after and keep the one that works.

While you write, the story bible files every character, place and event, and a summary of the whole book keeps up, so the want you gave a character in chapter one is still there in chapter twenty. It runs in any browser, has no subscription (packs from $3.50, and they never expire), and one free credit lets you try a tip on your own page in KudoNovel today.