How to Fix Pacing in a Novel: 25 Thriller Chapters Measured

How to fix pacing in a novel: we measured 25 chapters of two classic thrillers. The chases have the least dialogue; the slowest chapter is 94% dialogue.

By Published November 19, 20269 min read

Try KudoNovel for free
  • No subscription needed
  • Unfiltered & uncensored
  • Story Bible that updates itself

To fix pacing in a novel, find the chapters where nothing changes, then cut their run-up, merge them, or make something happen in them; don't just shorten sentences or add dialogue. We measured all 25 chapters of two classic thrillers, The Thirty-Nine Steps and The Hound of the Baskervilles, and the fastest chapters (the chases and the hound itself) have far less dialogue than their books average, while the slowest, the explaining chapter, is 94% dialogue. Pace is what happens per page, and the numbers below show how to check yours.

What the usual advice on pacing says (checked November 2026)

SourceIts fix
Jessica Brody (10 Feb 2021)Find where a slow scene really starts and cut what comes before: "when do the characters start actually DOING something?"
Reedsy (Dario Villirilli, updated 14 Oct 2025)Vary it with sentence length, description, subplots, dialogue, cliffhangers and action: "A single story can't (and shouldn't) be all fast or all slow."
Bryn Donovan (28 Jun 2017)List the 5 or 6 events that change the story, note the page each begins on, and look for long gaps and crowded clusters.

Brody's run-up cut and Donovan's map of turning points are the two that hold up in the count below. The surface fixes (shorter sentences, more dialogue) don't match what these two books do.

Pacing in two thrillers, chapter by chapter

Checked 19 November 2026: the Project Gutenberg texts of John Buchan's The Thirty-Nine Steps (1915, ebook 558) and Arthur Conan Doyle's The Hound of the Baskervilles (1902, ebook 2852), from the pglaf.org mirror, split at their chapter headings. "Dialogue" is the share of words inside quotation marks; sentences are split at full stops, so "Mr." shortens the average a little.

ChapterWhat happensWordsDialogueWords per sentence
The Thirty-Nine Stepswhole book: 40,780 words, 27% dialogue
1Scudder's story; Scudder found dead4,63841%15.9
2Hannay escapes north by train2,4997%17.2
3The innkeeper, the aeroplane, the notebook4,60618%17.2
4The radical candidate's meeting4,32623%16.8
5Disguised as the roadman3,52125%14.4
6Captured by the archaeologist; blows his way out6,1339%16.8
7Sir Walter; Karolides shot4,13227%14.8
8The Black Stone at the meeting2,92834%14.2
9Hunting for the steps on the coast2,55051%12.1
10The spies taken5,42739%15.6
The Hound of the Baskervilleswhole book: 59,114 words, 59% dialogue
1Holmes reads the walking stick2,24373%13.0
2The legend read aloud; the footprints3,85194%21.3
3The problem2,89488%11.0
4Sir Henry and the stolen boot4,05580%12.8
5Three broken threads3,41279%11.2
6Baskerville Hall3,49139%15.9
7The Stapletons4,96858%13.2
8Watson's first report2,7603%19.7
9The convict on the moor6,65438%16.3
10Extract from Watson's diary3,66051%14.1
11The man on the tor4,56640%14.3
12Death on the moor4,83467%12.8
13Fixing the nets3,44171%12.7
14The hound attacks4,17130%14.9
15A retrospection: Holmes explains4,08494%21.4

Source: KudoNovel's count of the Project Gutenberg texts, 19 November 2026.

What the 25 chapters say:

The fastest chapters talk least. Buchan's two chases, the train north (ch. 2) and the escape from the archaeologist's house (ch. 6), are the two lowest-dialogue chapters in his book, at 7% and 9% against 27% for the whole. Doyle's climax, the hound on the moor (ch. 14), is 30% against 59%. When things happen, the narrator tells you what happens; nobody stops to discuss it.

Short sentences don't make a chapter fast. Buchan's chases average 17 words a sentence, his book's longest. His shortest sentences, 12.1, are in chapter 9, where Hannay is standing on a cliff working out a riddle. Long, driving sentences full of verbs move faster than short ones that describe.

Dialogue that explains is the slowest thing in a book. Doyle's last chapter is 94% dialogue and 21.4 words a sentence, the book's highest on both: Holmes explaining the case to Watson after it's over. Chapter 2, the legend read aloud, is the same shape. Both are short enough to survive, and Doyle puts them where the reader wants the information: at the start and after the climax.

Long chapters aren't the problem; long chapters where nothing changes are. The longest chapters in each book, Steps ch. 6 (6,133 words) and Hound ch. 9 (6,654), are a capture and escape and a night hunt for an escaped convict. Chapter length alone tells you where to look, not what's wrong.

How to find the slow chapters in your own novel

Make the table above for your book. It takes an evening.

  1. One line per chapter: what changes in it. Not what happens: what's different at the end. If the line reads "she thinks about it" or "they discuss the plan", mark it.
  2. Its word count. Mark any chapter more than half again as long as your median.
  3. How much of it is explanation. Characters telling each other what the reader already knows, or what happened off the page. Doyle gets away with one chapter of this at the end; a draft often has four in the middle.
  4. Read only the marked chapters, in a row. A chapter marked on all three counts is your fix list.

Where those chapters sit matters. A run of marked chapters between the hero committing and the midpoint is the classic sagging middle; in story structure for novels we measured where those turns fall, and a sag usually means a missing turn near 50%.

The fixes, by what you find

The chapter starts too early. Brody's cut: find where someone first does something, and start there. Keep the setting, but move it into the action.

Two chapters do one job. If chapter 11 and chapter 12 both end with the heroine suspecting her sister, merge them and keep the better scene.

A chapter explains. Turn the explanation into a discovery the heroine makes, or cut it and trust the reader. If it must stay, put it where the reader is hungry for it, as Doyle does, never between two quiet chapters.

The middle repeats. Raise the cost each time. The convict hunt in Hound ch. 9 is a second night on the moor, but this time Watson finds a man on the tor.

It's too fast. The rarer problem, usually in the last act: a death or a confession handled in a paragraph. Give the moment a scene of its own with what the point-of-view character notices and feels. Our thriller guide covers where the slow beats belong in a fast book.

A slow paragraph, fixed

Before (the paragraph explains):

Tess went over everything again in her head. The ledger had been in the drawer on Monday, and now it wasn't, which meant someone with a key had taken it, and only three people had keys: Marcus, the cleaner and herself. She thought about each of them in turn.

After (something happens):

The drawer slid open on nothing. Tess counted the keys on the hook by the door: two. Marcus's was gone, and his coat was still on his chair.

What changed: the reasoning went into an action (counting keys), the three suspects became one clue, and the paragraph went from 49 words to 28. Sentence length barely moved. The change is that the second version happens.

Questions writers ask about pacing

What is pacing in a novel? How fast the story seems to move: how much changes per page, and how long the reader waits between changes. Sentence rhythm is part of it, but the table shows it's the smaller part.

How do I know if my pacing is too slow? The chapters you skim when you reread, and the ones beta readers stop in. On paper: chapters whose one-line summary has no change in it.

Does dialogue speed up pacing? Quick exchanges in a confrontation do. Explaining dialogue slows it: the slowest chapter in Hound is 94% dialogue.

How long should chapters be for good pacing? Neither book keeps them even: Buchan's run from 2,499 to 6,133 words, Doyle's from 2,243 to 6,654. Vary them by what happens, not by a target.

How do you fix a saggy middle? Add a turn near the midpoint that changes what the heroine wants, and cut one of any two chapters doing the same job.

Fixing pacing in KudoNovel

Pacing fixes are edits to passages you already have, and that's what KudoNovel's Steer does: highlight the stretch that explains and type a line ("she finds it instead of thinking it through"), and it plans which sentences the instruction reaches and edits those, leaving the rest as you wrote them. Tighten is one of its quick buttons for a paragraph that runs long. Every Steer is a version on the paragraph's map, so you can try a cut and go back. For the opposite problem, a death or a confession that goes by in two lines, Expand fills the moment out from your own words.

Because each chapter keeps a record and the book a running summary, updated when you leave a chapter, the one-line-per-chapter list from the method above is already half made when you go looking for the slow ones.

Fix the slow chapters in KudoNovel: one free credit to try it, then one-off credit packs, no subscription. Import the draft from Word or Scrivener and its chapters come in as they are.