Unreliable Narrator: How to Write One, With 9 Narrators Counted

How to write an unreliable narrator: we counted hedges and protests in nine classics. Christie's liar reads like Jane Eyre; Poe's killer protests most.

By Published November 19, 20268 min read

Try KudoNovel for free
  • No subscription needed
  • Unfiltered & uncensored
  • Story Bible that updates itself

An unreliable narrator is a narrator whose account the reader can't fully trust, because they lie, leave things out, misunderstand, or deceive themselves. To write one, decide which kind yours is, write down what really happened, and then write the narrator's version with every sentence technically true to their view. We counted the hedges, protests and memory words in nine classic first-person narrators: the best liar of the lot, Christie's Dr Sheppard, uses them at almost exactly the rate of honest Jane Eyre and Jim Hawkins. The narrators who give themselves away are the ones fooling themselves.

What the top guides say about unreliable narrators (checked 19 November 2026)

SourceThe advice
Writer's Digest (Deb Caletti, 21 Dec 2015)Make the narrator a liar, withhold information, blur motives, make her "craftier than she seems", let secondary characters catch the lie.
Writers Helping Writers (Becca Puglisi, 26 Feb 2026)Establish a normal baseline first, add small inconsistencies, use lost time carefully, retell a key event with shifting details.
NovlrGive the narrator a reason, and write a timeline of the actual events the reader never sees.

Good advice, and none of it tested. The usual idea is that an unreliable narrator sounds unsure, or protests too much. We checked whether the famous ones actually do.

Do unreliable narrators sound unreliable? Nine narrators, counted

We took each text from Project Gutenberg, removed everything inside quotation marks so only the narration is left, and counted three kinds of words per 1,000: hedges (I think, I suppose, I fancy, perhaps, maybe, seemed, I don't know), protests (I assure, I swear, truth, truly, honest, indeed, certainly, of course, I am sure, I knew, no doubt) and memory (I remember, I recall, I forget, as far as I).

NarratorKindHedgesProtestsMemory
Dr Sheppard, The Murder of Roger Ackroyd (1926)the liar2.851.960.03
The governess, The Turn of the Screw (1898)self-deceived, perhaps2.312.990.67
The wife, The Yellow Wallpaper (1892)breaking down4.573.510.53
The killer, The Tell-Tale Heart (1843)mad, says he isn't2.964.430.00
Nick Carraway, The Great Gatsby (1925)partial2.440.740.26
Lockwood and Nelly, Wuthering Heights (1847)partial2.460.830.08
Huck, Huckleberry Finn (1884)naive1.670.590.08
Jim Hawkins, Treasure Island (1883)reliable2.632.240.14
Jane, Jane Eyre (1847)reliable3.521.910.16

Source: KudoNovel's count of the Project Gutenberg texts (Ackroyd, Turn of the Screw, Yellow Wallpaper, Tell-Tale Heart, Gatsby, Wuthering Heights, Huckleberry Finn, Treasure Island, Jane Eyre), 19 November 2026. The Turn of the Screw counted from the governess's manuscript. Word lists are blunt: "seemed" and "I knew" are also ordinary narration, so read the gaps between rows, not the second decimal.

The liar writes like an honest man. Sheppard hedges a little less than Jane Eyre and protests about as often as Jim Hawkins. His memory count is the lowest in the table: a man hiding ten minutes doesn't draw attention to remembering.

The self-deceived protest. Poe's killer, Gilman's wife and James's governess are the top three for protests, and the governess and the wife lead on memory too. Poe's first line is the pattern: "True!—nervous—very, very dreadfully nervous I had been and am; but why will you say that I am mad?"

The naive and the partial barely use these words at all. Huck's unreliability is in his judgments (he thinks he's going to hell for helping Jim), not in his grammar. Nick claims honesty once, a third of the way in ("I am one of the few honest people that I have ever known"), and lets you test it against the book.

So pick the kind first. A narrator who deceives the reader on purpose should sound like Jane Eyre. One who deceives herself can over-insist, and the reader will start to count.

How Christie hid it in one sentence

Here is the passage, in chapter 4, 15.7% of the way into The Murder of Roger Ackroyd:

The letter had been brought in at twenty minutes to nine. It was just on ten minutes to nine when I left him, the letter still unread. I hesitated with my hand on the door handle, looking back and wondering if there was anything I had left undone.

Poirot names Sheppard at 96.2% ("You're mad," he answers), and in the last chapter, "Apologia", at 97.7%, Sheppard quotes those lines back: "All true, you see. But suppose I had put a row of stars after the first sentence! Would somebody then have wondered what exactly happened in that blank ten minutes?"

That's the technique in one line: every sentence true, the gap between two of them doing the lying. "Wondering if there was anything I had left undone" is not a hedge. It's a man checking the dictaphone he has just set.

Write the true timeline, then the told one

Before writing chapter 1, fill two columns for every key scene. Here is Christie's, rebuilt from her book:

What happenedWhat the narrator tells
8:40 the letter arrives. Before 8:50 he kills Ackroyd and sets the dictaphone for half past nine."It was just on ten minutes to nine when I left him, the letter still unread."
Once the body is found, he slips the dictaphone into his bag and pushes the chair back against the wall."I did what little had to be done."

Source: Sheppard's own account in the "Apologia", which quotes both lines back.

Then for each row, decide which of the four moves it uses: a lie, a gap, a misreading, or a fact told in the wrong order. Christie uses the gap and the true-but-partial sentence; the governess misreads; Poe's killer lies to you while confessing. A book that uses all four on one scene shows its hand.

A narrator's line, before and after

Before (the author winks):

I swear I had nothing to do with Leo's accident, though I suppose nobody will believe me now.

After (a self-deceived narrator; the reader counts):

I was home by eleven. I remember the time because the news was ending, and I remember the news because they showed the bridge. I didn't think anything of it. Why would I?

What changed: the denial is gone, and the protest moved into memory and a question. The reader starts to wonder why she remembers so precisely, which is the governess's register in the table, not Sheppard's.

Questions writers ask about unreliable narrators

What are the types of unreliable narrator? Four that cover most books: the liar (Sheppard), the self-deceived (the governess, Poe's killer), the naive (Huck, who doesn't understand what he sees), and the partial (Nick, Nelly Dean, who like some people too much). The term itself comes from Wayne C. Booth's The Rhetoric of Fiction (1961).

Can a third-person narrator be unreliable? Yes, through close third that shares a character's blind spots, but it's harder to play fair: readers assume a third-person narrator tells the truth, so they feel cheated. Our first person vs third person guide covers what each lets you hide.

When should the reader find out? For a liar, as late as the plot allows (Christie: 96%). For a self-deceived narrator, gradually; the reader should suspect long before the narrator admits anything.

How do I keep it fair? Every clue to the truth has to be on the page. Rereading should show you the ten minutes. Our guide to how to write a mystery novel has the fair-play rules, and plot twist ideas covers twists that recast the whole book.

Keeping two versions of the story in KudoNovel

The hard part of an unreliable narrator is holding two stories for 300 pages: what happened, and what she says happened. In KudoNovel the first column can live in the story bible. Write the event entry yourself ("8:45: she takes the car keys from his coat"), and the AI never rewrites an entry you wrote or edited. The page holds only the told version: type the narrator's line rough, press Expand, and it becomes prose from your words, in her first person. When a sentence gives too much away, highlight it and Steer it ("true, but leave out what she did next"), and Versions keeps the franker draft in case you need it for the reveal.

Start the told version in KudoNovel: one free credit to try it, then one-off credit packs, no subscription. If your draft is already in Word or Scrivener, import it and keep going.