Good mystery story ideas start with three things: a crime, a reason this person is the one who investigates, and a lie that everyone around her is telling. The books that win say so. We sorted the fourteen Edgar Award Best Novel winners from 2013 to 2026: five are set in the past, three have no detective at all, and only three follow a private eye. Below are that count, a count of three popular idea lists, and five mystery ideas built the winners' way.
What the Edgar winners are built on (counted 19 November 2026)
The Edgar for Best Novel is the Mystery Writers of America's top prize. We took every winner from 2013 to 2026 from the award's list and sorted each by who investigates and when it's set. The 2026 winner, Robert Crais's The Big Empty, was reported by Kirkus; Flags on the Bayou's setting is from its publisher.
| Year | Winner | Who investigates | When |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2013 | Live by Night, Dennis Lehane | No detective: a gangster's story | 1920s–30s |
| 2014 | Ordinary Grace, William Kent Krueger | A 13-year-old boy | 1961 |
| 2015 | Mr. Mercedes, Stephen King | A retired police detective | Now |
| 2016 | Let Me Die in His Footsteps, Lori Roy | A family, two generations apart | 1930s and 1950s |
| 2017 | Before the Fall, Noah Hawley | A plane-crash survivor, and the investigators | Now |
| 2018 | Bluebird, Bluebird, Attica Locke | A Texas Ranger | Now |
| 2019 | Down the River Unto the Sea, Walter Mosley | An ex-cop turned PI | Now |
| 2020 | The Stranger Diaries, Elly Griffiths | A teacher, and a police detective | Now |
| 2021 | Djinn Patrol on the Purple Line, Deepa Anappara | A nine-year-old boy | Now |
| 2022 | Five Decembers, James Kestrel | A Honolulu police detective | From 1941 |
| 2023 | Notes on an Execution, Danya Kukafka | No detective: the women around a killer | Decades, to now |
| 2024 | Flags on the Bayou, James Lee Burke | No detective: a war novel | 1863 |
| 2025 | The In Crowd, Charlotte Vassell | A London police detective | Now |
| 2026 | The Big Empty, Robert Crais | A PI | Now |
The counts: police or Rangers lead in four, a PI or ex-cop in three, an ordinary person (two of them children) in five, and nobody investigating in three (The Stranger Diaries splits the job between a teacher and a detective, so it is counted twice). Five of fourteen are set mostly in the past. None is a cosy.
Then we counted three of the idea lists ranking for "mystery story ideas" today:
| Idea list | Ideas | A murder | Set in the past | Investigator not stated |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Write Practice (no date shown) | 25 | 17 | 5 | 4 |
| Bryn Donovan (5 September 2017) | 50 | 16 | 2 | 44 |
| Fictionary (12 October 2024) | 46 | 9 | 3 | 15 |
| Total | 121 | 42 | 10 | 63 |
Ten of 121 ideas are set in the past, against five of fourteen winners. And 63 of 121 don't say who investigates, which is the decision that tells you what kind of book you're writing.
What people search for
"Mystery story ideas" runs about 480 searches a month in the US (Google Keyword Planner, checked 19 November 2026). The People Also Ask questions under it are about what makes a mystery work, which the five questions below answer.
Five mystery story ideas, developed
Every idea answers the same five questions:
- The crime: what happened, in one line, and why it looked like nothing.
- Why her: the reason she, and nobody else, keeps asking.
- The lie: what everyone around her is hiding, which isn't always the murder.
- The fair clue: the detail planted early that solves it, in plain sight.
- The reveal: who, and what it costs her to know.
1. The funeral cake (amateur, small town)
- Crime: a retired headmaster dies of a "heart attack" in a Somerset village.
- Why her: Nell, the baker, took his funeral cake order the day before he died, from his son.
- Lie: the whole village knew he was selling the school field for houses, and half of them signed something.
- Fair clue: the order slip says "for Thursday" in the son's writing, dated Tuesday.
- Reveal: the son ordered it as a joke, and the joke gave someone else the idea.
2. The ward clerk's rota (police, now)
- Crime: three patients on the same hospital ward die within a month, each signed off as expected.
- Why her: DC Amara Osei's mother was the third.
- Lie: the ward has been short-staffed for a year and the rota covers it up.
- Fair clue: every death falls on a night the rota shows a nurse who was on holiday.
- Reveal: the deaths were neglect, not murder, and the person who forged the rota did it to keep the ward open.
3. The diver's logbook (historical, 1950s)
- Crime: in 1954 a pearl diver goes down off Broome and doesn't come up; the boat calls it the bends.
- Why her: Iris, the boat owner's widow, keeps the books and the logbook says he surfaced.
- Lie: the crew have been selling pearls on the side, and the dead man was going to tell her.
- Fair clue: his air line was coiled left-handed, and only one man on the boat coils left.
- Reveal: the left-handed man is the one she trusted with the business.
4. The sister's shift (no detective, the people around it)
- Crime: a man is found guilty of killing his wife; the book opens the night before his appeal.
- Why her: told by his sister, the wife's best friend, and the juror who voted guilty last.
- Lie: each of them has told the court a smaller truth to protect a bigger one.
- Fair clue: two of them describe the same coat, in different colours.
- Reveal: no twist on who did it; the twist is which of them knew before the trial.
- Note: this is the Notes on an Execution shape: a crime novel with no detective, where the question is what the crime did to the people near it.
5. The PI's own missing person (private eye, now)
- Crime: a podcaster hires a Glasgow PI to find a man missing for ten years.
- Why her: Fiona Baird took the original case and dropped it.
- Lie: the podcaster isn't his daughter; she's the daughter of the woman he left with.
- Fair clue: the podcaster knows his middle name, which was never in the press.
- Reveal: he isn't missing; he's been living two streets from Fiona's office.
If you're building idea 1 or 3, the clue has to be fair: our guide to how to write a mystery novel counted where eight classics first name the culprit, and our plot twist ideas measured where the twist lands in nine classic novels: the first clue at 18% of the book, the reveal at 66%. If you want a faster engine than a puzzle, how to write a thriller novel covers the clock.
Where the idea lists fall short
The lists give you a body and a setting. Most stop there: of 121 ideas, 63 don't say who investigates and almost none says what the people around the crime are hiding, which is where a mystery's middle comes from. And they can't keep your clues straight. The order slip dated Tuesday, the coat in two colours, the left-handed coil: a mystery is a ledger of small facts, and in a draft you check each one by hand every time a later chapter leans on it. One slip and the reader who solved it fairly feels cheated.
Write it in KudoNovel
A fair mystery is a book where chapter two and chapter twenty-four agree. In KudoNovel you type the crime and the first scene as a rough paragraph and press Expand; it comes back as prose built from your words, and the story bible files the victim, the suspects and each detail you plant as entries on its own, so when the reveal comes, the clue reads the way you set it. Steer fixes a scene in a line ("she notices the date on the slip, says nothing"). You can also let it run: write the opening, then press Autopilot on the empty paragraph under it and KudoAI writes three beats in a row toward a "where it's heading" line you can edit, with twists that break no established fact if you pick Quentin Foxantino to direct. It's a browser app with one free credit to try it, then one-off credit packs and no subscription. Take the funeral cake or the diver's logbook, type the crime as your first paragraph, and plant the clue.