MM Romance Books: The 20 Readers Shelve Most, Counted

MM romance books ranked by Goodreads shelving (19 Nov 2026): the 20 most-shelved, and a count of how many are hockey, dark, fantasy or a first-time-with-a-man story.

By Published November 19, 20268 min read

Try KudoNovel for free
  • No subscription needed
  • Unfiltered & uncensored
  • Story Bible that updates itself

The MM romance books readers shelve most are Heated Rivalry by Rachel Reid, Him by Sarina Bowen and Elle Kennedy, and For the Fans by Nyla K., then Rina Kent's God of Fury and Casey McQuiston's Red, White & Royal Blue. That's Goodreads' MM romance shelf, which held 63,642 books when we read it on 19 November 2026. Below are the 20 most-shelved series, then a count of what they share: the sport, the dark books, the fantasy, and one trope that turns up in six of the 20.

The best MM romance books, by how often readers shelve them

Each number is how many times readers put the book on the shelf. Where a series has several entries we kept its highest (Reid's Game Changers has six books in the top 50).

#BookShelvedWhat it is
1Heated Rivalry, Rachel Reid900Rival NHL stars, a secret for years
2Him, Sarina Bowen and Elle Kennedy885Hockey, two friends from summer camp
3For the Fans, Nyla K.755Stepbrothers, forbidden
4God of Fury, Rina Kent653Dark, college, a mafia heir
5Red, White & Royal Blue, Casey McQuiston627The First Son and a prince
6Iced Out, C.E. Ricci554Hockey teammates who hate each other
7Top Secret, Sarina Bowen and Elle Kennedy493College, a hookup app
8Captive Prince, C.S. Pacat482Fantasy, a prince given as a slave to his enemy
9Fake Out, Eden Finley480Fake boyfriend for a wedding
10Garron Park, Nordika Night456Motocross rivals from a trailer park
11Boyfriend Material, Alexis Hall439Fake dating, London rom-com
12Don't You Dare, C.E. Ricci438Best friends, one dare
13Egotistical Puckboy, Eden Finley and Saxon James425Rival NHL players
14Wolfsong, T.J. Klune424Werewolves
15Kiss the Villain, Rina Kent416Dark, professor and student
16Soul Eater, Lily Mayne414Fantasy, a monster in the wastes
17Power Plays & Straight A's, Eden Finley391College hockey
18Unhinged, Onley James379Dark, a killer and the son of his victim
19You & Me, Tal Bauer378Single dads, friends
20Try, Ella Frank373Contemporary, a man who'll try anything once

Just past the top 20: Brea Alepoú's Take Me Apart, Madeleine Urban's Cut & Run, Alessandra Hazard's Just a Bit Twisted and Emmy Sanders's To Catch a Firefly. The Song of Achilles is 42nd, shelved 298 times.

What the 20 have in common, counted

The kinds below come from each book's own blurb and the genres Goodreads readers tag it with, read the same day.

KindOf the 20
Contemporary, no sport8 (For the Fans, Red, White & Royal Blue, Top Secret, Fake Out, Boyfriend Material, Don't You Dare, You & Me, Try)
Hockey5 (Heated Rivalry, Him, Iced Out, Egotistical Puckboy, Power Plays & Straight A's)
Dark romance3 (God of Fury, Kiss the Villain, Unhinged)
Fantasy or paranormal3 (Captive Prince, Wolfsong, Soul Eater)
Another sport1 (Garron Park, motocross)

Two counts across the categories tell you more than the genres do.

Rivals: 7 of 20. Heated Rivalry, Red, White & Royal Blue, Iced Out, Garron Park, Egotistical Puckboy, Captive Prince and God of Fury (the narrator is his enemy's twin) start the two men on opposite sides. That's the same pull as the enemies to lovers books readers shelve most, where Heated Rivalry and Red, White & Royal Blue also appear.

The first time with a man: 6 of 20. In Him, God of Fury ("I'm not attracted to men. Or so I thought"), Fake Out ("because I'm straight. At least, I think I am"), Don't You Dare ("I've always classified myself as straight"), You & Me ("bi awakening") and Try (tagged gay-for-you by readers), one hero has never been with a man, and the blurb says so. Thirty percent of the top 20 is built on one man's discovery. In the MM Romance Reader Survey 2022 (5,715 responses), bisexual awakening was on readers' list of favourite tropes. The shelf shows how often authors deliver it.

Hockey owns this shelf

Five of the top 20 are hockey, and it runs deeper below them. At least 16 of the shelf's top 50 entries are hockey romances: six of Reid's Game Changers, both Him books, five of Eden Finley's, Iced Out, Hidden Scars and The Understatement of the Year.

It works the other way too. On Goodreads' hockey shelf (11,312 books, read the same day), 10 of the top 50 entries are MM: Heated Rivalry is 5th, shelved 1,179 times, and Him, The Long Game, Game Changer, Role Model, Us, Iced Out, Tough Guy, Common Goal and Egotistical Puckboy follow. The rest of that shelf is mostly men and women, led by Elle Kennedy's The Deal, so one in five of the hockey romances readers shelve most is two men.

The TV adaptation of Heated Rivalry, which premiered in November 2025, is part of why: our guide to writing MM romance has the sales figures that followed it.

Who owns the MM shelf

AuthorEntries in the top 50
Eden Finley (some with Saxon James)9, across three series
Rachel Reid6, all Game Changers
Sarina Bowen (three with Elle Kennedy)4
C.E. Ricci3
C.S. Pacat3, the whole Captive Prince trilogy
Rina Kent3

Most of the shelf is indie and series-led: an author who lands with readers stays on it book after book. Of the six authors with three entries or more, only C.S. Pacat's trilogy is fantasy.

MM romance books by what you want

If you wantStart with
HockeyHeated Rivalry, Him, Egotistical Puckboy
RivalsHeated Rivalry, Iced Out, Red, White & Royal Blue
Funny and sweetBoyfriend Material, Red, White & Royal Blue
Fake datingFake Out, Boyfriend Material (more in fake dating romance)
A first time with a manHim, Fake Out, You & Me
DarkGod of Fury, Unhinged, Kiss the Villain: check the content notes first
FantasyCaptive Prince, Wolfsong, Soul Eater
MonstersSoul Eater (more in monster romance books)
Older heroesYou & Me, two single dads
LiteraryThe Song of Achilles

Questions readers ask about MM romance books

What is the most popular MM romance book? On Goodreads' MM romance shelf, Heated Rivalry by Rachel Reid, shelved 900 times on 19 November 2026, just ahead of Him (885).

What does MM mean in books? A romance between two men (M/M, male/male). It's a category of romance, so the story ends with the two together.

Is MM romance spicy? Often, not always. Red, White & Royal Blue and Boyfriend Material are lighter; the dark three on the list are not. In the 2022 survey, 45% of readers said they don't mind the heat level if the book is good. For heat ratings, see closed door vs open door romance.

What should I read after Heated Rivalry? The rest of Game Changers, The Long Game first for Shane and Ilya, then Him and Egotistical Puckboy. Google's Keyword Planner puts "mm romance books" at 2,900 US searches a month (read November 2026).

Want to write your own?

The shelf tells you what MM readers come back for: two men on opposite sides, a series that keeps going, and often one of them discovering what he wants. Writing it means keeping two heroes' histories straight for a long time: who said what at the camp four years ago, who knows the secret. In KudoNovel you write the moment rough (he waits in the empty rink after the game) and Expand turns your words into prose, keeping your events. The story bible keeps up by itself as you write, so both men's pasts are in view in chapter thirty. And if you'd rather watch it unfold, Autopilot writes the next beats on its own while you read, three at a time, with a slow-burn director, Sofia Catpola, who lingers in the moment. It's a browser app; one free credit to try it, then one-off packs, no subscription.

Pick your two men and what keeps them apart, and start the book.

Checked November 2026: Goodreads MM romance shelf read 19 November 2026 (positions 1 to 50), series collapsed to their best-placed book; each book's blurb and readers' genre tags read on its Goodreads page the same day (For the Fans from its publisher's listing); hockey shelf read the same day. Survey as published October 2022. Search volume from Keyword Planner, US, November 2026.