I Hate Everything I Write: Sort the Hate, Then Fix One Level

Hate everything you write? Hemingway's 1934 ratio, the taste gap, and a worked audit that turns 'it's all bad' into four fixable levels, before and after.

By Published November 19, 20266 min read

Try KudoNovel for free
  • No subscription needed
  • Unfiltered & uncensored
  • Story Bible that updates itself

If you hate everything you write, you're usually reacting to one of four separate problems at once: the story, the scene, the sentences, or the distance between your taste and your current skill. Each has a different fix and a different time to fix it, and only one of them can be fixed while you're drafting. So stop judging the whole thing, sort what you hate into those four levels, and deal with one.

It is also the most ordinary feeling in the job. Hemingway, in a letter to F. Scott Fitzgerald dated 28 May 1934, put his own ratio at "one page of masterpiece to ninety one pages of shit", as Quote Investigator records.

Is it normal to hate your own writing?

Yes, and the people you'd least expect said so on the record. We checked the famous lines writers pass around, because half of them are misquoted.

Checked 19 November 2026:

The line you've seenWho, and the real sourceChecked
"The first draft of anything is shit."Attributed to Hemingway, but first printed in Arnold Samuelson's 1984 memoir With Hemingway, 23 years after Hemingway diedQuote Investigator, 2015
"One page of masterpiece to ninety one pages of shit"Hemingway's own words, letter to Fitzgerald, 28 May 1934Same
He rewrote the last page of A Farewell to Arms 39 timesHemingway, Paris Review interview, Spring 1958. Asked what had stumped him: "Getting the words right."Paris Review; The Morgan holds the revised typescript
"All good writers write them" (shitty first drafts)Anne Lamott, Bird by Bird, Pantheon, 1994Brandeis reprint of the chapter
"Your taste is why your work disappoints you" (the gap)Ira Glass, 2009 interview, widely transcribedKottke, April 2011

Glass's point is the useful one. You started writing because you have good taste, and for a while your taste is ahead of what you can do, so everything you make falls short of what you can tell it should be. He says the only way through is a large volume of work. Hating your draft is the gap showing, not proof that you can't write.

Why do I hate my writing when I reread it?

Because you're reading it as an editor while it's still a draft. When you reread a scene the day after writing it, you know what you meant, so you see every place the page falls short of it, and none of what a reader would enjoy. The Go Teen Writers advice (23 August 2023) is to note where you are in the process: doubt tends to peak in the middle of a draft. It also says to make your list of dislikes specific: "State 'why' or 'because' for each one if you can." That one instruction is the whole method below.

When you hate everything you write, sort it into four levels

Write down what you hate, in plain words, then put each item in a row.

LevelWhat it sounds likeFix it whenFix
Story"Nothing happens", "Why would she even stay?"Now, before more pagesOne line per remaining scene; change the plan, not the prose
Scene"It drags", "They just talk", "Too much explaining"After the draft, or the next morningCut the setup, start late, give someone a want in the scene
Sentence"Flat", "Clichéd", "Clunky"RevisionLine edit later; stock phrases are easy to find and swap
The gap"It's not as good as the books I love"Never directlyFinish things. The gap closes with volume, not with rewriting one chapter

Only the first row stops a draft. The rest feel urgent and aren't. Most writers who hate everything are trying to fix row three during the draft, which is how chapter one gets rewritten eleven times and chapter two never starts.

A worked example: one hated paragraph, audited

Here's a short draft paragraph of the kind people hate, written for this page:

Nora walked into the bakery. She was nervous because she hadn't seen Callum in ten years and she still loved him, which was stupid. He looked up from the counter and smiled and her heart did a flip. "Hi," she said. "Hi," he said.

"I hate it" isn't useful. Sorted:

  • Story: fine. Ten years, an old love, his bakery: that's a situation.
  • Scene: it tells us she still loves him in the second sentence, so there's nothing left for the scene to show. The dialogue carries no tension.
  • Sentence: "walked into", "her heart did a flip": stock.
  • Gap: you'd like it to read like your favourite second-chance romance. That's not today's job.

So only the scene and sentence rows need work, and here's a rewrite that addresses both:

The bell over the bakery door still stuck halfway. Callum didn't look up until it rattled free, and by then Nora had counted the scones twice. "We're closed," he said, then saw her face, and set the tray down very carefully.

What changed: the feeling is in what they do (counting scones, the careful tray), the old familiarity is in a detail (the bell still sticks), and the first line of dialogue is a small refusal instead of "Hi". The story didn't change at all, which is the point: the version you hated was a usable draft of this scene.

Should I delete it and start over?

Almost never during a draft. Keep the scene, mark it, write the next one. Deleting feels like a fix and costs you the raw material, the details you'll want later. If the story row is the problem, change the plan and carry on from where you are; you can make chapter one match the new plan in revision. If you've stopped because of this feeling and can't restart, writer's block sorted by kind of stuck has the fix for perfectionism, and the advice is the same: rules loosened, pages kept.

When the hate is telling you something real

Two cases. If you hate only this book and not your others, the story row may be the true one: the premise isn't one you want to write. And if what you hate is the dialogue specifically, that's a learnable skill with clear rules: dialogue that sounds human covers them. Neither is a reason to stop writing; both are reasons to fix one level on purpose.

Drafting rough on purpose in KudoNovel

The sentence row is the one that stops people, so KudoNovel lets you skip it while drafting. You type each paragraph the way the bakery scene started, as rough as it comes ("Nora comes in, bell sticks, he says they're closed, then sees it's her"), and Expand writes it out as prose from your words, keeping your events. If the result is wrong, you don't delete it: Steer takes a one-line instruction ("less telling, let her not answer him") and edits the paragraph in place, or just the part you highlight. Tighten is one press on the Steer row.

Changes are kept as versions. Each paragraph has its own Versions map, and Undo and History above the page walk back through the whole chapter, so a paragraph you hated on Tuesday is still there on Thursday when you realise it had the line you need. The story bible fills itself in as you go. One free credit to try it after confirming your email, then one-off packs, no subscription.