How to Write a Book Series: What Anne and Sherlock Got Wrong

How to write a book series: we counted the Anne books and found Doyle's slips. Anne drops from 118 to 12 mentions per 10,000 words; Watson's wound moves.

By Published November 19, 20267 min read

Try KudoNovel for free
  • No subscription needed
  • Unfiltered & uncensored
  • Story Bible that updates itself

To write a book series, decide what each book resolves on its own and what only the whole series resolves, then keep one record of every fact the books share: names, ages, scars, dates, who knows what. That record is the job most series writers underestimate. Arthur Conan Doyle moved Watson's war wound from the shoulder to the leg between the first two Holmes novels, and had Mrs Watson call her husband "James" a year later. We checked both in the texts, and counted how L. M. Montgomery's Anne books handed their series from one cast to another.

What the top guides say about writing a series (checked 19 November 2026)

SourceThe advice
The Creative Penn (Joanna Penn, 13 Jul 2018)Seven continuation issues: consistent traits and history, how much to repeat for new readers, "what you remember writing" versus what you wrote, each book complete, the arc per book or per series, time passing, the covers.
Writer's Digest (Susanna Calkins, 9 Aug 2019)Don't spend everything in book one; plan arcs; watch the clock; "Keeping a compendium across books is crucial"; keep the copy editor's notes.

A reader comment under Penn's post says it all: "I discovered I had it wrong in my series bible, so now I have to go check the other books." The guides tell you to keep the record. Here is what goes wrong when it slips, and how a long series actually moves its cast.

Continuity errors in a famous series, found in the text

FactWhereWhat the text says
Watson's woundA Study in Scarlet (1887)"There I was struck on the shoulder by a Jezail bullet, which shattered the bone"
The Sign of the Four (1890)"sat nursing my wounded leg. I had a Jezail bullet through it some time before"
Watson's first nameA Study in Scarlet"the Reminiscences of JOHN H. WATSON, M.D."
"The Man with the Twisted Lip" (1891)His wife: "Or should you rather that I sent James off to bed?"

Source: the Project Gutenberg texts of A Study in Scarlet, The Sign of the Four and The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, searched 19 November 2026.

Same bullet, same battle, three years apart, a different part of the body. Holmes fans have spent a century inventing explanations for both; a reader of your book three will simply notice. Both of Doyle's slips are the kind Penn calls "what you remember writing", facts written once, early, and recalled wrong.

How the cast changes over a long series: the Anne books, counted

We counted how often each name appears per 10,000 words across the first five Anne books.

BookWordsAnneGilbertMarilla"Matthew"
Anne of Green Gables (1908)102,510117.611.082.4360 times
Anne of Avonlea (1909)91,098110.37.931.915
Anne of the Island (1915)76,568134.723.613.20
Anne's House of Dreams (1917)79,39095.236.98.114
Rainbow Valley (1919)80,92512.01.20.50

Source: KudoNovel's count of the Project Gutenberg texts (1, 2, 3, 4, 5), 19 November 2026. Names per 10,000 words, except Matthew, counted in mentions.

Three things a series writer can take from that table:

The love interest grows book by book. Gilbert is a rival in book one (11 per 10,000 words) and the husband by book four (36.9). The romance arc runs across the series, not inside one book, which is Calkins's first lesson in practice: Montgomery didn't spend the wedding in book one.

The dead stay in the record. Matthew dies in Anne of Green Gables, and his name still comes up 15 times in the next book and 14 in the fourth, always as memory: "the little girl Matthew brought home here fourteen years ago." That line is also a clock. A series bible needs dates as well as people, so a memory lands on the right year.

A series can hand itself to new leads. In Rainbow Valley Anne falls to 12 mentions per 10,000 words, and the Meredith children take the book: Faith alone is named 447 times. Anne is mostly "Mrs. Dr. dear" (56 times) in other people's mouths. If your series will move to the next generation or a side couple, plant them a book earlier: Anne's son Jem is born in House of Dreams, and by Rainbow Valley he and Walter (137 mentions) share the book with the Merediths.

The series bible fields that catch these errors

Every guide says keep a bible. Fewer say what columns stop the mistakes above. Build each character entry with these, and fill them the day you write the fact, not afterwards:

  1. Body, with sides: scars, wounds, tattoos, and which side. Watson's error is a missing "left shoulder".
  2. Every name used: full name, what each person calls them, nicknames. "James" was a name nobody wrote down.
  3. Dates: birth year, and the year of each book's events, so "fourteen years ago" can be checked.
  4. Status at the end of each book: alive, married, moved away, and who knows the secret.
  5. First appearance: book and chapter, for the reader who starts at book three.
  6. Open threads: what this book raised and didn't close, and which later book closes it.

Field 4 is also how you decide what to recap. A new reader of book two needs each returning character's status, in a clause, the first time they appear. They don't need the plot of book one.

Questions writers ask about writing a series

Should I plan the whole series before writing book one? Plan the ending of the series and what each book resolves on its own. Leave the middle loose. Montgomery published the first five books over eleven years and the cast still moved on in a way that reads as planned, because each book closed its own story.

How much should book two recap? As little as a new reader needs to follow the scene: who this is to the hero, in one clause, when they first appear. Penn lists it as one of the seven issues; the bible's field 4 tells you which clause.

Standalone books or one continuous story? Both sell. A series of standalones (Holmes) lets readers start anywhere; a continuous story (a trilogy with one villain) needs every book to end on a closed question and an open one.

How long should each book be? Keep the length steady so readers know what they're buying: the five Anne books above all fall between about 76,000 and 103,000 words.

Do I need software to track a series? You need one place where every fact lives and can be searched. Our AI story bible guide compares the ways to keep one, and why the AI forgets your story covers what happens to that record inside a chatbot.

Writing book two in KudoNovel

The hard part of book two is that book one's facts live in a finished manuscript you'd have to reread. In KudoNovel, import book one (Word, EPUB, Scrivener and more) and press Rescan in the story bible: it reads the whole book (it spends credits) and files the people, places, items and events, each in its own entry. Then write the next book's chapters: the bible keeps reading as you go, and before Expand writes a paragraph it picks the entries that paragraph needs, so Mara's scar is on her left wrist in book two because the entry says so. Correct an entry by hand ("left wrist, not right") and the AI never rewrites what you wrote. There's no cap on chapters, so a whole series can live in one place.

Start your next book in KudoNovel: one free credit to try it, then one-off credit packs, no subscription to keep paying between books. If your character arcs run across books, plan them with how to write a character arc.