How to Foreshadow in a Story: Every Setup in The Monkey's Paw

How to foreshadow in a story: we mapped all 14 setups in The Monkey's Paw to their payoffs. Thirteen come before the halfway mark, and four are a son's jokes.

By Published November 19, 20268 min read

Try KudoNovel for free
  • No subscription needed
  • Unfiltered & uncensored
  • Story Bible that updates itself

To foreshadow in a story, plant each hint in the first half, make some of them look like jokes or small talk, and let one payoff answer several of them at once. W. W. Jacobs's "The Monkey's Paw" (1902) is the classic case, so we mapped every setup in it to the moment it pays off. Of its 14 setups, 13 sit before the halfway mark, the median at 38% of the story, and every payoff falls between 61% and 100%. Four of them are the son's jokes, which is why first-time readers don't see them coming.

What the usual advice on foreshadowing says (checked 19 November 2026)

SourceWhat it tells you
Jericho Writers (Laura Lam, undated)Direct (prologues, prophecies, a character who knows more) and indirect (imagery, motifs, weather). "The overall aim of foreshadowing is to build suspense, tension, and intrigue."
Scribophile (Alex Cabal, undated)Plan the plot first, place hints early and spread them evenly, use them sparingly, ask a beta reader if they land.
Helping Writers Become Authors (K.M. Weiland, 28 Apr 2013)A plant and a payoff for every hint, subtle enough to be seen only in hindsight; back foreboding with specific clues.

All three give kinds and rules; none takes one story and lists every hint in it with where it falls. That's what the table below is.

Every setup in The Monkey's Paw, mapped to its payoff

Method, 19 November 2026: the Project Gutenberg text (ebook 12122, 3,937 words from "Without, the night was cold and wet" to the last line), from the pglaf.org mirror. A position is the share of the story's words before the line. Which lines count as setups is our reading; each is quoted so you can check it.

SetupWhereKindPays off asWhere
Mr. White plays chess "putting his king into such sharp and unnecessary perils"1%Character habitHe takes the paw from the fire and wishes35%
"Hark at the wind"2%Weather"A cold wind rushed up the staircase"99%
"only two houses in the road are let"5%Setting"a quiet and deserted road"100%
The fakir "wanted to show that fate ruled people's lives, and that those who interfered with it did so to their sorrow"17%Direct warningHerbert "caught in the machinery"61%
"the third was for death. That's how I got the paw."21%Direct warningMr. White's "third and last wish"98%
"If you keep it, don't blame me for what happens"26%Direct warningThe man from Maw and Meggins at the door57–61%
"it twisted in my hand like a snake"38%The rule shown working"Two hundred pounds"67%
Herbert: "I don't see the money… and I bet I never shall"38%JokeHe never does: it's paid for his death67%
Herbert: "something horrible squatting up on top of the wardrobe watching you as you pocket your ill-gotten gains"41%JokeThe compensation, then the knock67%, 89%
A face in the fire "so horrible and so simian"42%ImageThe knock "so quiet and stealthy"89%
Herbert: the money "Might drop on his head from the sky"46%JokeIt comes by an accident to his body61%
"you might if you so wished attribute it to coincidence"47%The rule stated"A coincidence," stammered the old man78%
Herbert: "don't break into the money before I come back"47%JokeHis last words; he doesn't come back61%
"I could only recognize him by his clothing"79%Fact held backWhat the father fears is behind the door89–98%

Source: KudoNovel's reading of the Project Gutenberg text, 19 November 2026.

How to foreshadow, from what the 14 setups show

Plant in the first half, pay off in the second. Thirteen of the 14 setups come before 50%; every payoff but the first comes after 57%. The one late setup ("recognize him by his clothing", 79%) isn't a hint about the plot; it raises the cost of the payoff already coming. So Scribophile's "spread them evenly" isn't what Jacobs did: he front-loaded them. In a novel, the same split holds at a larger scale: our count in plot twist ideas put the median first clue at 18% of nine classic novels and the median reveal at 66%.

State the rule, then show it working. The fakir's warning (17%) and the first owner's third wish (21%) tell the reader how the paw works. The twist in the old man's hand (38%) proves it does. By the time the money arrives, the reader has been told the rule twice and seen it once, so the payoff feels inevitable instead of convenient.

Hide the sharpest hints in jokes. Four setups are Herbert's jokes: the money dropping on his head, "don't break into the money before I come back", the thing on the wardrobe, "I bet I never shall". Each is a precise forecast of his own death and the payment for it, said so lightly that the parents laugh. A hint delivered by a character who doesn't believe it is the easiest one to slip past a reader.

Let one payoff answer several setups. The knock at 89% pays off the face in the fire, the wardrobe joke and the clothing line together. The last paragraph pays off the wind at 2% and the empty road at 5%. A payoff that answers three hints feels like the story closing; one that answers none feels made up.

Start the atmosphere on line one. The wind and the empty road are in the first 5%. Neither is a clue to the plot; both come back in the last sentence.

Direct vs indirect foreshadowing, counted

KindSetups in the storyExample
Direct warning3"don't blame me for what happens"
The rule stated or shown2"it twisted in my hand like a snake"
Joke4"Might drop on his head from the sky"
Setting, weather, image3"Hark at the wind"
Character habit1the reckless chess
A fact held back1"I could only recognize him by his clothing"

The direct warnings are all said by one man, the sergeant-major, in the first 26%, and then he leaves the story. After he goes, every hint is indirect. That's a pattern you can copy: let one character say it plainly early, remove them, and let the rest come in sideways.

A foreshadowing line, before and after

Before (the hint announces itself):

Grace had no idea that the old well would one day hold the answer to her sister's disappearance.

After (the hint as a joke, in scene):

"If Lily ever runs off for good," her father said, dropping a stone down the well, "that's the first place I'll look." Lily laughed loudest.

What changed: the narrator stopped telling the reader to remember the well, a character joked about it instead, and the person the joke is about laughs at it, as Herbert does.

Questions writers ask about foreshadowing

What is an example of foreshadowing? Herbert's "don't break into the money before I come back" at 47% of "The Monkey's Paw": he dies before he comes home, and the money is the price of his death.

How early should you foreshadow? In the first half, and the atmosphere on the first page. Thirteen of the 14 setups here are before 50%.

How do you foreshadow without giving it away? Put the hint in the mouth of someone who doesn't believe it (a joke), or next to a wrong explanation, which is the trick our plot twist count found in all nine novels.

What's the difference between foreshadowing and Chekhov's gun? Chekhov's gun is the rule that what you show must be used; foreshadowing is the hint that it will be. The paw on the mantelpiece is the gun; the fakir's warning is the foreshadowing.

How much foreshadowing is too much? "The Monkey's Paw" has 14 setups in under 4,000 words and still surprises, because only three are direct. If most of yours are warnings, turn some into jokes or images.

For a longer book built on hints, our guides to how to write a mystery novel and horror that actually scares cover clue placement and dread over a full length.

Keeping your setups straight in KudoNovel

The hard part of foreshadowing in a novel isn't the hint; it's remembering, at chapter 20, the exact words you planted at chapter 2. KudoNovel's story bible files characters, places, items and events by itself as you write, so the joke about the well becomes part of what the book knows, and before Expand writes a paragraph it picks the entries that paragraph needs. An entry you write or edit yourself is never rewritten by the AI, so you can note "the well: Lily's hiding place, never say so" and it stays that way.

Plant your first setup in KudoNovel: one free credit to try it, then one-off credit packs, no subscription.