The fantasy story ideas that sell aren't the ones most idea lists hand out. We counted where the last twelve Goodreads Choice fantasy winners are set: eight happen in our own world, with magic hidden inside it, and only one is the medieval invented-kingdom quest that fills the prompt lists. Below are that count, a count of three popular idea lists, and five fantasy novel ideas built the way the winners are built: the magic, what it costs, who it's hidden from, what she wants and the first scene.
Where fantasy readers' favourite books are set (counted 19 November 2026)
Goodreads Choice is voted by readers, so it's the nearest thing to a list of the fantasy people actually pick up. We took every Fantasy winner from 2013 to 2025 from the award's winners list and sorted them by setting. Neil Gaiman's Trigger Warning (2015) is a story collection, so it's left out.
| Year | Winner | Where it's set |
|---|---|---|
| 2013 | The Ocean at the End of the Lane, Neil Gaiman | Our world: rural Sussex, a farm with something old in it |
| 2014 | The Book of Life, Deborah Harkness | Our world: witches and vampires in Oxford and beyond |
| 2016 | Harry Potter and the Cursed Child (play), J. K. Rowling | Our world, wizarding Britain hidden inside it |
| 2017 | Fantastic Beasts (screenplay), J. K. Rowling | Our world: 1926 New York |
| 2018 | Circe, Madeline Miller | Greek myth retold |
| 2019 | Ninth House, Leigh Bardugo | Our world: Yale's secret societies |
| 2020 | House of Earth and Blood, Sarah J. Maas | Invented world, with phones and cars |
| 2021 | A Court of Silver Flames, Sarah J. Maas | Invented world, faerie courts |
| 2022 | House of Sky and Breath, Sarah J. Maas | Invented world, with phones and cars |
| 2023 | Hell Bent, Leigh Bardugo | Our world: Yale again |
| 2024 | Somewhere Beyond the Sea, T. J. Klune | A version of our world, an island orphanage |
| 2025 | Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil, V. E. Schwab | Our world, across three centuries |
Eight of twelve are set in our world or its past, one is myth, and three are invented worlds. Two of those three have smartphones. A Court of Silver Flames is the only castles-and-courts book on the list.
Then we counted three of the idea lists Google ranks for "fantasy story ideas" today, sorting each idea by setting the same way:
| Idea list | Ideas | Set in our world | Set in an invented world | Setting not given |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dabble Writer (1 March 2024) | 50 | 0 | 9 | 41 |
| The Write Practice (no date shown) | 20 | 13 | 1 | 6 |
| Spines (6 July 2025, updated August 2026) | 54 | 8 | 14 | 32 |
| Total | 124 | 21 | 24 | 79 |
Most of the ideas (79 of 124) never say where the story happens. That's the first decision a fantasy writer has to make, and it decides almost everything after it: who the magic is hidden from, what a phone call does to your plot, whether the reader needs a map.
What people search for
| Search | US searches a month |
|---|---|
| fantasy story ideas | 1,300 |
| fantasy novel ideas | 1,000 |
| fantasy plot ideas | 320 |
Source: Google Keyword Planner, US, checked 19 November 2026. The "novel" version is nearly as big as the "story" one: people want an idea that will carry a book, not a scene.
Five fantasy novel ideas, developed
Each idea answers the same five questions, so you can run your own through them:
- The magic and its price: what it does, and what it takes from the one who uses it.
- Who it's hidden from: in our-world fantasy, the secret is half the plot.
- What she wants: something ordinary that the magic gets in the way of.
- The first scene: one small piece of magic, in a place the reader knows.
- The turn: the point where the price comes due.
1. The pawnbroker who buys luck (our world, urban)
- Magic and price: Wren runs a pawnshop in Leeds that buys luck. Sellers walk out with cash and a run of bad days; she sells the luck on to people with interviews and court dates. Every sale costs her a little of her own.
- Hidden from: her sister, who thinks the shop sells watches.
- Want: to pay off her late father's debts and close the shop by spring.
- First scene: a woman in a wedding dress pawns "all of it" and leaves smiling. Wren can feel the weight of it in the drawer.
- Turn: the bride's luck goes missing from the safe, and every buyer she has served starts winning at once.
2. The ferrywoman of the canal (our world, folk)
- Magic and price: a narrowboat on the Kennet and Avon carries the newly dead to wherever they're going. The woman who steers it ages a day for every passenger.
- Hidden from: the boaters she moors beside every night.
- Want: Ada, 61, wants one season off the water before her knees give out.
- First scene: a man in a cycling jacket knocks on the hatch and asks if this is the right boat.
- Turn: a passenger refuses to get off, and he is someone she buried.
3. The archivist's indexed spells (our world, dark academia)
- Magic and price: in a university library, spells are catalogued like books. Casting one erases it from every copy on earth, so each use is the last.
- Hidden from: the faculty who think the restricted floor holds rare maps.
- Want: Priya wants her PhD funding renewed.
- First scene: she reshelves a spell for mending glass and the card catalogue updates itself in ink.
- Turn: someone is casting through the collection in alphabetical order.
4. The orphan exchange (a version of our world, cosy with teeth)
- Magic and price: magical children are registered by a government office; a caseworker who signs a placement is bound by it until the child turns eighteen.
- Hidden from: no one; that's the problem. The town knows exactly what the children are.
- Want: Marguerite wants a quiet posting after twenty years of inspections.
- First scene: a seven-year-old sets her clipboard on fire, politely.
- Turn: the office orders the home closed, and her signature is on every file.
- Note: the island orphanage for magical children is the ground Somewhere Beyond the Sea won on in 2024, so make the office, the town and the price your own.
5. The cartographer's debt (invented world, for contrast)
- Magic and price: in a river kingdom, land exists only where it has been mapped. Mapmakers draw new ground into being, and lose the memory of the place they were born for each map they sign.
- Hidden from: nobody; it's the kingdom's economy, and the guild owns it.
- Want: Teodora wants to draw her mother's village back before she forgets it.
- First scene: she inks a jetty at dawn and a fisherman ties his boat to it before the ink is dry.
- Turn: the guild orders her to unmap a rival city, with people in it.
If you're building idea 5, a magic system with a cost has to be set before chapter one, and our guide to how to write a fantasy novel measured how early nine classics show it: every one within the first 4% of the book.
Fantasy plot ideas: where each one goes from the first scene
An idea is a premise. A fantasy plot needs the price to rise in steps. For each of the five, three rungs:
| Idea | First rung | Second rung | Third rung |
|---|---|---|---|
| Luck pawnbroker | A buyer wins too much | Her sister buys luck behind her back | Wren must sell her own to cover the safe |
| Canal ferrywoman | A passenger asks to see his daughter first | She lets him, and the river rises | The dead man is her husband |
| Indexed spells | A minor spell vanishes from the collection | The thief reaches "H", for healing | Priya's own name is on a card |
| Orphan exchange | An inspection is scheduled | A child is moved without her signature | The binding pulls her to the child, wherever he's taken |
| Cartographer | A road she drew floods | The guild audits her maps | She finds her own village on the list to unmap |
Where the idea lists fall short
The lists are a fine place for a spark. But 79 of the 124 ideas we counted don't say where they happen, none of the 124 gives the magic a price and a want together, and the Write Practice list leans on comic one-liners (a dragon at the opening of a health food shop). They also can't keep your rules for you. The cost you set in chapter one (a day of age per passenger, one memory per map) has to be checked by hand every time the magic is used again, and a draft that forgets it breaks the book.
Write the idea in KudoNovel, and let it run
Fantasy breaks when the rules drift: the spell that cost a memory in chapter two is free by chapter fifteen. In KudoNovel you type the idea as a rough first paragraph and press Expand; it becomes prose in your own words, and the story bible files the magic, its price and the people it touches as entries without being asked, so every later chapter is written with the rule in view. When you want to see where an idea goes before you plan it, press Autopilot on the empty paragraph under your opening: KudoAI drafts where the story is heading, which you can edit, then writes three beats in a row while you read, and you pick a director for the pace (Sofia Catpola lingers, Quentin Foxantino twists). It's a browser app with one free credit to try it, then one-off credit packs and no subscription. Take the pawnbroker or the ferrywoman, paste the idea in as your first paragraph, and see what chapter one looks like.